Theropod Thursday 50: fruit salad, here I come!

Dieser Beitrag auf Deutsch.

When you ask an average person what a theropod is you will most likely get either a blank stare, or “Tyrannosaurus!!!” or “RAPTOR!!!!” yelled at you. Carnivores, both of them, and quite potentially hypercarnivores at that. Other people will start talking about “raptors” and so forth – and it will all be killing and scavenging and so on. Even if you happen to meet one of these enlightened ones who knows that extant birds are theropods, very likely you’ll hear about Zombie Tits eating bat and bird brains, about falcons impact-killing other birds in the air, and whatnot. Yes, the vast majority of people is aware that many birds are not carnivorous, but if you use the term “theropod” or “dinosaurs” they will instantly forget.

Extant theropods, however, differ enormously in their diets. Yes, lots of them are pure carnivores, just think of all the eagles and falcons and so on out there. Insectivorous species abound, too. And then there is the enormous range of birds who will basically eat anything, with a strong preference for meat – invertebrate or vertebrate. Most gulls come to mind, and many corvids, too. The rest? Lots of highly specialized or generalist herbivorous species, fruiteaters, seedeaters, whatnoteaters.

And in the fossil record? Are there indications that all this diversity in diet existed before the K/T boundary? Before active flapping flight? Before any kind of flight? Or way further down the tree, let’s say end-Triassic?

No, I won’t really answer those questions in this post. Rather, they lead me to an issue Darren Naish of TetZoo fame recently brought up in a comment on a Facebook post of the photo of a Pal-nut vulture (Gypohierax angolensis) below:

“To those who don’t know: Gypohierax is an obligate frugivore. I’ve been trying to find out whether we’d known this from its anatomy.”

Gypohierax angolensis

I don’t know much about vultures, but the German wikipedia page on the Palmgeier has some helpful info:

“Palmgeier sind mittelgroße, recht kräftig gebaute Greifvögel mit breiten, aber relativ kurzen Flügeln, einem sehr kurzen, gerundeten Schwanz, recht kleinem Kopf und kräftigem und langem Schnabel.”

(from de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palmgeier under CC-by-sa-3.0 license)

So, Palm-nut vultures are mid-sized, rather sturdily built raptors with a broad but relatively short wings, a very short and rounded tail, a rather small head and strong and long beak.

Hm, wing proportions. The depth of a wing is hard to tell from a fossil, unless the feathers are preserved. Tail shape and length? Same. Overall size is not a tell-tale sign of adaptation to an unusual diet either. A small head? The beak size and shape? Hm, especially the latter might trigger me to think “odd for a vulture, very loooong”. So if we found this animal as a feathered fossil, we might start to think that golly, this does differ quite a bit from many other Old World vultures. But would we conclude that adults’ diet consists of up to 2/3 fruit, and juveniles even over 90% fruit? I am quite sure we would not!

palmnut_02

One more – note that the bird is blinking!

palmnut_04

So overall, should we expect to recognize atypical diets in fossils? Not normally, if the species in question hasn’t had much time to adapt. Because, as commentor Dartian wrote in response to a TetZoo post on vultures here, usually, it takes a while for morphology to catch up with ecology.

To emphasise the point, here is another atypically feeding raptor, the Pern or European Honey Buzzard (Pernis apivorus). Look at it and tell me you can tell that this bird’s diet consists mostly of bee and wasp larvae!

palmnut_03

Nah!

So the take-home message today is: you can deduce the typical diet of a major group from the features you find consistently on the skeletons of the group. But you can’t tell the diet of individual species with any kind of certainty!

About these ads

About Heinrich Mallison

I'm a dinosaur biomech guy working at the Museum für Naturkunde Berlin.
This entry was posted in Aves, Dinopics, Dinosauria, Maniraptora, Theropoda, Zoos. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Theropod Thursday 50: fruit salad, here I come!

  1. Pingback: Theropoden-Donnerstag 50: Fruchtsalat, ich komme! | dinosaurpalaeo auf Deutsch

  2. Lars Dietz says:

    The one you identified as a Honey Buzzard is actually a Harris Hawk (Parabuteo unicinctus), famous for being a cooperative hunter and therefore popular among falconers. Although I agree it wouldn’t be possible to identify P. apivorus as an insectivore based on the skeleton alone. It does have a rather weakly built head, however, almost looks like a pigeon’s head with a hooked bill.

    • Lars – Harris Hawk is possible; I am clueless about raptors. However, the sign I photographed right after the above picture said Honey Hawk, I can’t find any photo of a Harris Hawk sign, and I can’t find any photos of similar-but-different hawks that could be the real Honey Hawk.

  3. Lars Dietz says:

    I don’t know about the sign, but this is definitely an adult Harris Hawk (see e. g. this picture). I don’t think there are any other hawks that can be easily confused with it, until recently it was the only species in its genus (P. leucorrhous, which is now also classified there, looks rather different), The real Honey Buzzard looks very different, e. g. see here.

  4. Robby Gilbert says:

    So hey, with these thoughts in mind, is there an any known or hypothisized example in the “dinosaur” world where having fossilized teeth collected and studied has led to some sort of unknown / non-traditional diet? With these bird images, I can more easily see just how damned hard it would be since they all appear to have these vicious looking beaks. Hopefully my question makes sense. I had no idea about the Palm Nut Vulture or Honey Buzzard! Just awesome stuff!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s